There's no evolution, just terrible media. It's de-evolution, literal demons can't just be evil anymore, they're all poor, marginalized immigrants/minorities. Freiren for example caused an uproar because the modern audience lost their minds because Demons were literally just evil.
@Joseph Lee "Was there a panic about Pokémon and Harry Potter?" Yes? A huge one? It was a subject of national conversation for years? I have to assume you're a teenager who was too young to have noticed at the time; it's the only way you could fall for "UGH WOKE RUINED EVERYTHING" nonsense
Равен Кроу
20 days ago
"Become a weirdo with in-depth knowledge of century old books. Do it."
And this will make anyone an order of magnitude better person than when they confuse "Ideas must evolve" with deliberate degradation under the "woke" banner.
This comic is 5 pixels away from becoming a "woke bad" rant.
Ideas must evolve, they always are.
And if you happen to like "the glorious past", that's cool too. Because there's a lot of it. Like, A LOT. Dive right in. Become a weirdo with in-depth knowledge of century old books. Do it.
Boar Childerich
21 days ago
I find this highly misleading, real "classic" fantasy had no overly sexy armor yet.
OtomeSound
23 days ago
Badly handled modern fantasy is bad. I can agree with that. I don't think there's anything bad about some nuance though.
Fantasy writers who are bad at nuance should stop trying to write nuanced fantasy, or at least LEARN from it.
Joseph Lee
23 days ago
(3/2)
Yeah, 3 out of 2 again. Me and leaving bits out. My entire point is that yes, SOME (allegedly) Christian groups/denominations freaked out about stuff like Pokémon and Harry Potter. It was a fringe minority. Basically, the further back you go, the more momentum these things had.
Joseph Lee
23 days ago
(2/2)
I knew Christians who PERSONALLY avoided them, or even cautioned others against them, but it wasn't something our local church (or overall denomination) worried about. HOWEVER, if you went by news coverage, the antis were "everywhere". ;)
Joseph Lee
23 days ago
(1/2)
Thanks, Reutan. I left out a "Yes." after "Was there a "panic" about Pokémon? Harry Potter?" Pretty bad error, since its absence changes the meaning of the comment. Even though I'm an "Evangelical" Christian, I still was big into Pokémon and HP...
Once upon a time the "what if the monsters were actually just like us," trope was interesting, but it's just so god damn overdone at this point that it's legitimately a breath of fresh air to see demons actually be inherently evil.
Jezebeth Noir
26 days ago
POSTMODERN FANTASY
Raised to be a weapon. Doesn't know who she is without the cause. Also did questionable things. Tries to be better, but keeps failing. Exhausted. Conflicted. Still believes in something. Maybe.
The child may symbolize lost innocence, a future, or his own lost childhood.
Jezebeth Noir
26 days ago
DARK FANTASY
Self-righteous bastard. Enjoys having moral authority (no matter how many people die). Holy mission. Loves the authority. Not much different from the monster.
Cruel bastard. Knows exactly what he is. Enjoys frightening people.
I did like the plot twist of "The real bad guy is (Insert Government, Religion or Monarch here)" when I first saw it. These days its on my bingo card of tropes for new shows.
Joseph Lee
26 days ago
3/2
Sorry for going over, but as a reminder, Chronicles of Narnia and Lord of the Rings are, to varying extent, "Christian" works. Plenty of fantasy is Christian. Plenty of people criticizing fantasy are NOT Christian. Karens be Karens.
Write good stories. That's what really matters. :)
Joseph Lee
26 days ago
(2/2)
Was there a "panic" about Pokémon? Harry Potter? Unlike with D&D, I was old enough to remember enough firsthand experience to know that the reporting on it was disproportionate. As in, I was an "Evangelical Christian" in the American Midwest. I was big into Pokémon & HP.
Joseph Lee
26 days ago
I wish to add perspective sorely lacking from some comments.
The Satanic Panic that decried D&D was in the 1980s. It was stupid, and 50 years from now, we'll have something as stupid or WORSE to cringe over from the 2020s. Notice how we still have a D&D SATam cartoon from the 1980s. (1/2)
(CONT'D) if you can't find any, you're either not looking hard enough or the author is themself a bigot because OBVIOUSLY the demons MUST be a stand-in for some race or nation.
They're not. They're literally monsters who evolved to hunt humans and have developed tricks to that end. That's it.
Also, people these days apparently struggle with separating reality with fantasy. Case in point, the demons in Frieren. They are Evil with a capital E. Baby-eating, puppy-kicking Evil. But oh no, we can't have that, they simply MUST have SOME redeeming traits somewhere, and (CONT'd)
Chiribito Sardina
26 days ago
Another example, the irredimible evil. A fantasy creature that is evil is bad, but find in media a rich capitalist antagonist that is not considered irredimible evil. The point is not to shift the blame, the point is to represent conflict on a mature way be it justified or not [2/2]
J L
26 days ago
I think Swagner has a point
Society has spent centuries literally demonising things like appearances, other cultures, hobbies, mental illnesses, races, religions counter culture and more. And I mean literal, they compared a hobby about pretending to be a garden gnome called Elvis to actual satan.
Chiribito Sardina
26 days ago
I feel like most modern fantasy tries to invert the tropes but just half-hearthed. Do you not like bikini armor? Do not use it. But the hard truth is sexy sells no matter how many time has passed or how much we think we are ethically advanced we consider us now. [1/2]
I mean, given how many christians have spent the last couple decades calling any and all fantasy "satanic", it's hardly surprising that the people actually left to write any wouldn't be eager to rehabilitate the "fanatic zealot on a bloody crusade".
Jonathan Woodward
27 days ago
The plot twist of the kid being the (most) evil one still works, even if you stay classic for everything else. Perhaps this demon troll needs to be saved from The Ransom of Red Chief.
Deconstruction of traditional tropes was fun for a while, but the deconstruction became clichéd on its own. I think it's time to deconstruct these new tropes and go back to noble elves, the good guys being good, the bad guys being bad, and a final lair over a smoking volcano.
Joseph Lee
27 days ago
When done WELL I can enjoy both. Some of it is upbringing; BEFORE I read Tolkien, I was exposed to WarCraft II (NOT WoW, old school WarCraft!).
Then, for tabletop RPGs, I cut my teeth on GURPS. Which was happy to let you have evil orcs, misunderstood orcs, etc.
There comes a point where the inversion of tropes starts becoming the norm and it gets more than a little tiresome. It's only funny if the norm remains the norm so you CAN invert it.