*remembers the two strips Jo actually did draw himself*

The real you is too realistic. You'd get accosted by fans when you go out and you just don't wanna deal with that. Imposing works for me, but maybe with some tweaks so people don't connect it to Baldur's Gate.

Cute girl has my vote~ Surely nothing unwholesome would happen to her~

The rejected JJBA villain of the week isn’t great, and I think you’re overlooking the obvious solution.
Split the differences between cutie & illithid, for something like Sucker For Live.

Cute’thulhu.

We all know Jo's face reveal should display the truth we all know: Jo is a huge tentacle with tentacles of his own, and what we see is the comic is really one of his smaller tentacles

Aaah, come on...

Froggo Jo is cute too.

The most complex Jo, the harder to draw. I like the Day of Tentacle reference, even if too old for current gamers. We don’t need a Handsome Squidward-chan.
I like the current behavior “make a strip about the current popular game”, this will attract other gamers from different communities.

Damn, man. Real you has a chin so chiseled that you could cut diamonds with it. And that hat just completes it.

As a super nerd, I say embrace your inner Illithid.

Cute Jo is best. Waifu are supreme. Jo as a waifu is peak degeneracy. Would also answer where the tentacles come from.

Your tentacle avatar does have a face! It has two eyes, and the last panel even implies it has eyebrows. Maybe add some suckers or something as a mouthline?

For my two cents, I like #2

I kinda wanna see the other girls react to this forms

you should embrance your imposing side! it definitely defines you better than current form!
just kidding, but could be nice see you represent yourself in such a form for a couple of strips

I actually like the frogge one.

Illithid!! Illithid!! Mind-flayer!!
It's cute and I like it a lot

I say go with a combination of Imposing and Real. Just be purple Handsom Squidward with tentacles on your chin.

Plot twist: Tentajo always have been a cute monstergirl, all this time she have been trying to appeal to foot fetishists so she used her foot as avatar.

Cute Jo: Have girl-on-girl tentacle action!

Le Chad Jo

you could do something similar to that inkling persona of yours just for the facial expressions

Protoss-Mind Flayer Jo would be more on-character. Also, Zone-tan would approve.

Classic version is best version... Though the fact algorithm lady failed to pick the cute version shows how flawed she is... And the fact she also failed to pick the real version is an utter crime!

If that is Just OK Joe, what would Handsome Joe look like?

Maybe Lorgar?